Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sean Valdrow's avatar

A splendid essay. At last, someone isn't trying to recreate the past but to ensure a brighter future.

As one of my blacksmithing books begins, "Old is not obsolete and new is not better.'

In the years I've been alive, I have seen the internet come, I have seen it foment a revolution in backyard metal casting, I have seen a revolution in amateur smithcraft with the spread of homebuilt power hammers and the sharing of information, I have seen a resurrection of knowledge and crafts and skills once thought too estoeric or archaic to be of value.

I follow one fellow reconstructing an alchemical laboratory in the 18th-century style, just to learn where modern chemistry comes from. ( the "fraser builds" channel on YouTube)

I follow another fellow who is an astonishingly skilled clockmaker and machinist. He's currently reconstructing a replica of the Anti-Kythera Mechanism, a mechanical astronomical clock from the second century BC. He's approximating the tools and techniques used in those ancient days as he recreates one tiny fiddly bit after another. These ancient tools and techniques still work. (the "Clickspring" channel on YouTube.)

Knowledge requires physical action to be of value. Being able to actually DO stuff makes one independent. The Wright brothers didn't buy engines for their flyers; they built them, improving each model as they progressed. There was NO ONE to buy engines from... it was make it yourself or do without.

These ancient books were written by men who had a tremendous practical understanding of the world. Many of these ancient books need primers for moderns to fill in the missing knowledge. Our lack of practical skills in the modern day leaves many utterly handicapped for want of real skills; I teach blacksmithing and often run into kids who've NEVER DRIVEN A NAIL. How can this be?!

If you wish to build a bright future, include the practical, everyday useful skills in which to embody the higher knowledge. A man who cannot cast or forge metal, plant a garden, frame a building, or repair simpler machinery has no anchor for greater things.

Expand full comment
Dick Lichter's avatar

Gutenberg is great. I’ve read a lot of Conan stories off of it.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts